Short answer: they can fill a slow week, but they're a poor foundation to build a business on. You pay for each lead, you compete with three or four other electricians for the same job, and the day you stop paying, the leads stop. Here's the honest breakdown so you can decide where they fit — if at all.

How these services work

Angi (formerly Angie's List / merged with HomeAdvisor) and HomeAdvisor sell you leads. When a homeowner submits a request, it's sold to several pros in the area — typically three to four. You pay per lead whether or not you win the job, usually $15–$100+ for electrical work depending on job type and market. Some plans also charge membership fees.

Thumbtack works similarly — you set preferences, and when a customer's request matches, you're charged when you're introduced (Thumbtack's pricing has shifted over the years between pay-per-lead and pay-per-contact models). The customer usually contacts several pros.

The common thread: the lead is not exclusive, and you're renting access, not building an asset.

The real numbers

• Cost per lead: $15–$100+ for electrical, higher for big jobs (panels, rewires).
• Close rate: commonly 10–25% on shared leads, because you're one of several quotes and the customer is often price-shopping. That means your effective cost per booked job can be $150–$600+.
• Lead quality: a mix. Some are real and ready. Many are tire-kickers, wrong-service, out-of-area, or already hired someone. Disputing bad leads for credit is possible but takes time and isn't always granted.
• Reviews: these platforms keep the reviews. Build up 40 reviews on HomeAdvisor and they don't help your Google ranking or transfer anywhere.

When they actually make sense

• You're brand new with no Google presence, no reviews, and an empty calendar. A shared lead you close is better than no job. Use it as a bridge, not a destination. (See the new electrician first-90-days plan.)
• You have a genuine slow stretch and want to fill specific days.
• You want practice closing estimates and want volume to sharpen your process.
• You have a specific capacity to fill — a second tech sitting idle two days a week.

In all of these, the mindset is: supplement, capped budget, watched closely.

When they don't make sense

• As your main lead source. You'll spend years paying per lead and never build rankings, reviews, or referrals that produce leads for free.
• If your close rate on shared leads is under 15%. Do the math on effective cost per job — it's often worse than Google Ads.
• If you're competing on price to win them. Racing three other electricians to the bottom on a shared lead trains you to underprice.

The better use of the same money

Say you'd spend $600/month on Angi. Redirected:

• Google Local Services Ads — similar pay-per-lead model, but you get the "Google Guaranteed" badge, top placement, and the customer contacts you directly. Better close rates.
• A website + local SEO — a few months in, this produces leads at near-zero marginal cost, forever, and the reviews and rankings are yours. (Why electricians need a website.)
• A review engine — 5 new Google reviews a month compounds into Map Pack ranking.

Most electricians who've run both will tell you the same thing: the marketplace leads kept them alive early, and the owned channels (Google Business Profile, website, referrals) are what let them stop buying leads.

A reasonable approach

1. Months 0–3, new business: use one marketplace with a tight monthly cap while your owned channels have nothing. Track close rate and effective cost per job.
2. Simultaneously: build the website, optimize the Google Business Profile, start the review engine, turn on Local Services Ads.
3. Months 4–9: as owned channels produce, cut the marketplace budget.
4. Steady state: keep one marketplace as a "slow week" valve only, or drop it entirely.

For the full ranked list of channels, see how to get electrician leads.

FAQ

Is Angi worth it for electricians? As a bridge when you're new or genuinely slow, with a capped budget — sometimes. As a primary lead source — usually not, because leads are shared with several electricians, close rates run 10–25%, and you never build owned assets like rankings and reviews.

What's the difference between Angi and Google Local Services Ads? Both are pay-per-lead, but Local Services Ads give you top placement, a "Google Guaranteed" badge, and direct contact from the customer, which typically produces higher close rates. Angi and HomeAdvisor sell the same lead to multiple pros.

How much do electrician leads cost on these platforms? $15–$100+ per shared lead depending on job type and market, plus possible membership fees. With a 10–25% close rate, effective cost per booked job is often $150–$600+.

Do reviews on Angi or Thumbtack help my Google ranking? No. Those reviews stay on the platform and don't transfer to or influence your Google Business Profile. Focus review requests on Google.

What should I use instead of shared lead services? An optimized Google Business Profile, a website that ranks locally, a steady review habit, referrals, and Google Local Services Ads — channels you own or that give you exclusive, direct contact.

---

Build leads you don't have to rent

MagicSite builds the website, Google Business Profile presence, and review engine that let electricians stop paying per lead.

See MagicSite for electricians →